Chapter 5: “The Tragedy of Pondicherry Lodge”
Summary: They travel to the home of Thaddeus’ twin brother, but find that he’s been murdered by poison and that the treasure has been stolen.
Reaction: I’m very excited to learn that Sherlock is a good fighter! Just like in the movie! Now we need to see him in action!
Prediction: Sherlock will be on the case and find about twenty minute clues that will lead him to that wooden-legged pirate
Why This Book Is a Classic: Classic murder–creepy murder too. Seeing the man smiling unnaturally through a key hole. Then having to break the door down. It was awesome and classic.